Joe Rogan Experience #2580 - Kenneth Lacovara
Audio Brief
Show transcript
Imagine compressing all four and a half billion years of Earth's history into a single calendar year, where paleontologist Kenneth Lacovara explains that humans do not show up until twenty seconds before midnight on December thirty-first. On the November twelfth, twenty twenty-six episode of the Joe Rogan Experience, host Joe Rogan talks with Lacovara about the fossil record. By the end, you will understand how dinosaur anatomy, mass extinctions, and geology reveal deep time.
How to use Earth's timeline to predict where dinosaurs are buried. Because geology is predictive, finding non-avian dinosaurs requires targeting exposed sedimentary rock between roughly two hundred forty million and sixty-six million years old. That means rocks in upstate New York are too old, while rocks in Florida are generally too young.
Why fossilization has to start fast, and why dinosaur DNA is gone. In reality, permineralization, where minerals from groundwater fill bone pores, must begin within months to years to protect bones from bacteria and scavengers, even if turning completely to rock takes thousands of years. Also, no non-avian dinosaur DNA exists because the oldest individual DNA is just over one million years old, and Lacovara notes the jury is still out on a twenty twenty-five Curtin University claim of dinosaur blood, since molecular paleontologist Mary Schweitzer pointed out the bulk sample lacked the nuclear bulge expected in non-mammalian blood cells.
Once those bones are preserved, how paleontologists reconstruct a giant dinosaur and keep it from overheating. In South America, Lacovara discovered Dreadnoughtus, a titanosaur weighing sixty-five tons, heavier than a Boeing 737. By measuring upper arm and thigh bone circumferences and checking disordered outer bone cells, scientists proved this giant was still growing rapidly when it died, and avoided cooking from its own body heat by using honeycombed bones connected to bird-style lungs that kept air flowing in one direction.
How extreme heat drove both the rise and the fall of non-avian dinosaurs. Two hundred two million years ago, the fourth mass extinction happened when the supercontinent Pangaea ripped apart, releasing enough carbon dioxide to cause rapid global warming that knocked back dominant prehistoric crocodiles and let dinosaurs diversify. Then, sixty-six million years ago, an asteroid up to eighteen kilometers wide struck off the Yucatán coast, heating the global surface somewhere between a toaster oven and a pizza oven within an hour, wiping out surface-nesting dinosaurs while sparing burrowing and aquatic animals.
How a shark tooth, a rowboat, and nine years of barnacles unlocked deep time. In the sixteen hundreds, Nicolas Steno realized stone serpent tongues were fossilized shark teeth and wrote the laws of rock layering, and in seventeen ninety-five, Scottish geologist James Hutton proved at Siccar Point that the present is the key to the past. Convinced of deep time by Charles Lyell's geology book on the HMS Beagle, Charles Darwin delayed publishing Origin of Species for twenty-five years and spent nine years studying barnacles to build his expertise.
How ancient fossils sparked monster myths and a bitter scientific war. Author Adrienne Mayor calls it folk paleontology when ancient people invented monsters from fossils, like Mediterranean dwarf elephant skulls with a single central nasal opening inspiring the Cyclops. Later, a dispute at a New Jersey quarry sparked the Bone Wars when Yale's Othniel Marsh bribed a quarry owner to divert fossils from Philadelphia's Edward Drinker Cope, setting off decades of sabotage, gunplay, and Cope mistakenly mounting an Elasmosaurus head on its tail.
What flipping magnetic poles and ancient genomes reveal about recent extinctions. While a disputed twenty twenty-one study claimed a temporary magnetic shift forty-two thousand years ago depleted ozone and helped wipe out Neanderthals, Lacovara stresses this is outside his field and any link to mutations is guesswork. In genetics, he cites Beth Shapiro to note that modern humans collectively retain almost the entire Neanderthal genome.
For all the giants in the fossil record, remember that modern blue whales and coastal redwoods mean we actually live alongside the largest animals and trees in Earth's entire history. We live in an age of giants now.
Episode Overview
- Paleontologist Kenneth Lacovara tells Joe Rogan how the fossil record works, what we actually know about dinosaur anatomy and extinction, and how geology reveals Earth's deep history.
- The conversation begins by addressing skepticism about dinosaurs and young Earth creationism, moving into how Earth's 4.567-billion-year timeline and rapid mineralization processes govern where and how fossils are preserved.
- Lacovara details major paleontological discoveries from early British fragments and New Jersey marl pits to his own excavation of the 65-ton titanosaur Dreadnoughtus, while clarifying what science must still guess about soft tissue, feathers, and dinosaur DNA.
- The discussion expands into prehistoric crocodiles, the geological mechanics of the fourth and fifth mass extinctions, and the 17th- through 19th-century breakthroughs by Nicolas Steno, James Hutton, Charles Lyell, and Charles Darwin that established deep time.
- The episode concludes by exploring geomagnetic pole reversals, underground cities, cryptids, Neanderthal genetics, de-extinction efforts, avian-style dinosaur respiration, and the bitter 19th-century rivalry known as the Bone Wars.
Key Concepts
- Earth's Cosmic Calendar and Predictive Geology: If Earth's 4.567-billion-year history is compressed into a single calendar year starting January 1, complex life (like trilobites at 0.5 billion years ago) does not appear until Thanksgiving. Dinosaurs arrive in the second week of December and persist for 165 million years until an asteroid strikes on December 26, meaning they lived only 2% of Earth's history ago. Homo sapiens (300,000 years ago) arrive about 20 seconds before midnight on December 31. Because geology is a predictive science, finding non-avian dinosaurs requires locating exposed sedimentary rocks dated specifically between 237 million and 66 million years old; rocks in upstate New York are too old (yielding trilobites and eurypterids), while rocks in Florida are generally too young.
- Rapid Fossilization, Preservation Bias, and the Limits of Ancient DNA: Contrary to the popular idea that fossilization is a slow process taking millions of years, permineralization (where minerals precipitate out of groundwater into bone pores) must begin within months to years to stabilize remains before bacteria and scavengers destroy them, even if turning completely to rock takes thousands of years. Because fossilization requires sediment accumulation, mountain-dwelling species where erosion dominates leave almost no fossil record. Furthermore, no non-avian dinosaur DNA exists; the oldest DNA from a single individual is slightly over 1 million years old, and the oldest environmental DNA from sediment is about 2 million years old. Regarding a November 5, 2025 Curtin University article claiming chemically confirmed traces of 115-million-year-old dinosaur blood, Lacovara notes the jury is still out because molecular paleontologist Mary Schweitzer pointed out the sample was a bulk sample rather than a specific structure and lacked the nuclear bulge expected in non-mammalian blood cells.
- Reconstructing Dinosaur Anatomy (Dreadnoughtus and Respiratory Mechanics): Lacovara discovered Dreadnoughtus in South America, a titanosaur sauropod with a 30-foot neck and 40-foot tail weighing 65 tons (equivalent to about 13 African elephants or 9 T. rexes, and heavier than a Boeing 737-900), yet possessing a brain so small that two could fit inside a pint glass. Its mass was calculated using a tight correlation in modern quadrupeds between body mass and the minimum shaft circumference of the humerus and femur, while bone histology revealed disordered cells near the outer edge, proving the 65-ton animal was still growing rapidly when it died. Giant sauropods avoided cooking internally from metabolic heat thanks to pneumatized (honeycombed) skeletons connected to unidirectional, bird-style lungs that stage air in lower and upper bladders to maintain a continuous one-way flow of oxygen. However, paleontologists must still approximate soft tissues and colors; Lacovara notes there is some uncertainty about the Dreadnoughtus neck and skull because only two neck vertebrae, one tooth, and a jaw fragment were found (reconstructed using Futalognkosaurus and Sarmientosaurus via phylogenetic bracketing), and states there is no evidence for the speculative inflatable neck bladders depicted on Dreadnoughtus in Apple TV's Prehistoric Planet.
- The Mechanics of the Fourth and Fifth Mass Extinctions: Of the first four mass extinctions, the first two were driven by global cooling and the third and fourth by overheating. The fourth mass extinction (End-Triassic, ~202 million years ago) occurred when Pangaea rifted apart to unzip the Atlantic Ocean, creating a massive magmatic province that released enough CO2 to cause rapid global warming, knocking back dominant Triassic crocodiles (which predate dinosaurs and included bipedal forms like Postosuchus) and allowing dinosaurs to diversify. The fifth mass extinction (End-Cretaceous, 66 million years ago) occurred when an asteroid up to 18 km across hit off the Yucatán coast, blasting a crater 110 miles across and initially 12 miles deep (roughly the area of Massachusetts 12 miles deep). Trillions of millimeter-sized ejecta particles re-entered the atmosphere, using radiative heat to raise global surface temperatures to between a toaster oven and a pizza oven within an hour. Non-avian dinosaurs, which laid eggs in surface craters, were functionally extinct that day, whereas survivors were aquatic or burrowing animals (small mammals, turtles, lizards, crocodiles, and burrowing birds).
- The Discovery of Deep Time and Evolution: In the 1600s, Nicolas Steno realized Sicilian glossopetrae ("serpent tongues") were actually fossilized shark teeth and established three foundational laws of geology: superposition, original horizontality, and lateral continuity. In 1795, Scottish geologist James Hutton observed tilted vertical beach sediments cross-cut by horizontal layers at Siccar Point, Scotland, publishing Theory of the Earth and establishing uniformitarianism ("the present is the key to the past"). When young Charles Darwin boarded the HMS Beagle, he (like Isaac Newton before him) believed the Earth was 6,000 years old, until Captain FitzRoy handed him Charles Lyell's Principles of Geology, which convinced Darwin of deep time. Feeling insecure about his scientific credentials, Darwin delayed publishing Origin of Species for 25 years and spent 9 years studying barnacles to establish his expertise.
- History of Paleontology, Folk Myths, and the Bone Wars: Ancient peoples likely invented mythical creatures upon discovering fossils, a concept author Adrienne Mayor calls folk paleontology: Gobi Desert dinosaur vertebrae inspired dragons, beaked quadrupedal Protoceratops fossils inspired the Griffin, and Pleistocene dwarf elephant skulls on Mediterranean islands (Sicily, Malta, Crete) with a single central nasal opening inspired the Cyclops. Formally, British anatomist Richard Owen coined "dinosaur" in 1842 after early British finds (Megalosaurus, Hylaeosaurus, and Iguanodon), followed in 1858 by the first nearly complete dinosaur skeleton (Hadrosaurus) and the first discovered tyrannosaur (Dryptosaurus, one of about 28 known tyrannosaur species) in southern New Jersey. A dispute at a New Jersey quarry in Mantua Township sparked the late-19th-century "Bone Wars" when Yale's Othniel Marsh bribed a quarry owner to divert fossils away from Philadelphia's Edward Drinker Cope, setting off a decades-long rivalry involving quarry sabotage, gunplay, Congressional hearings, and Cope mistakenly mounting an Elasmosaurus head on its tail end.
- Geomagnetic Reversals, Genetics, and De-Extinction: Earth's magnetosphere (generated by a solid iron-nickel core rotating inside a liquid iron outer core) flips polarity on average every ~800,000 years (despite a 5-million-year span without a flip at the end of the Cretaceous), a phenomenon that helped US Naval officer and Princeton professor Harry Hess prove seafloor spreading and plate tectonics in the 1960s via ocean-floor magnetic stripes. While a 2021 study proposed the disputed "Adams Event" hypothesis—claiming a temporary magnetic excursion ~42,000 years ago (the Laschamps excursion) depleted ozone, increased UV radiation, drove humans into caves, and contributed to the extinction of Neanderthals and Australian megafauna—Lacovara stresses that geomagnetic reversals are outside his field, the mechanics are not fully understood, and any links to mutation rates are guesswork on his part. In genetics, however, Lacovara cites Beth Shapiro to note that collective modern human DNA retains almost the entire Neanderthal genome (Lacovara himself has more Neanderthal markers on 23andMe than 99% of customers, while Rogan has 57%), and praises the de-extinction work of Colossal Biosciences, where he discloses he serves as an advisor, noting that the last woolly mammoths only went extinct ~3,000 years ago on Wrangel Island.
Quotes
- At 0:01:33 - "This would require this massive conspiracy from different continents, different countries, people that have never met each other, people that didn't live at the same time. I think it's hard to scale a conspiracy like this, right?" - explaining why the global fossil record cannot be a coordinated hoax.
- At 0:02:03 - "Don't believe me, science isn't a belief system, right? Go outside and dig up some fossils for yourself." - emphasizing that paleontology relies on testable, repeatable physical evidence rather than faith.
- At 0:02:53 - "So you have to find rocks that are between about 237 million years old and 66 million years old to find non-avian dinosaurs—I say that because birds are dinosaurs." - explaining how geological age dictates where dinosaur fossils can be found.
- At 0:05:13 - "The first dinosaurs show up in the second week of December, and they persist for about 165 million years until an asteroid murders them the day after Christmas." - placing the reign of dinosaurs onto a one-year cosmic calendar of Earth's 4.5-billion-year history.
- At 0:05:31 - "And then our species, Homo sapiens, shows up 300,000 years ago—that's about 20 seconds before midnight on the last night of the year." - illustrating humanity's brief existence relative to deep geological time.
- At 0:06:40 - "There's a phrase I love, which is that unlikely things are likely to happen when happening happens a lot." - explaining how rare fossilization events accumulate across millions of years.
- At 0:10:05 - "We don't have any non-avian dinosaur DNA. We don't have any DNA that's that old. The oldest DNA that we have from a single individual is a little more than a million years, and environmental DNA, where you just sample the sediment and see what was in the environment, I think is about 2 million years." - clarifying the hard chronological limits of DNA preservation.
- At 0:12:19 - "So the process of fossilization is fairly rapid. Otherwise, you wouldn't have anything left to fossilize." - correcting the misconception that mineralization takes millions of years to stabilize a bone.
- At 0:21:08 - "So I always say that, you know, England is the birthplace of dinosaur paleontology, but southern New Jersey is the cradle of dinosaur paleontology." - highlighting the 1858 discovery of Hadrosaurus and Dryptosaurus in New Jersey marl pits.
- At 0:29:25 - "It's like a pissed-off turkey, right? So like if a Velociraptor is in your kitchen, it's more of an opportunity than a problem, you know, just like throw some carrots on and, you know, have some Velociraptor roast later that night." - contrasting real feathered Velociraptors with the Deinonychus-sized predators in Jurassic Park.
- At 0:34:05 - "You could probably fit, you know, two Dreadnoughtus brains in a pint glass, you know, and it's a 65-ton organism. So they weren't thinking deep thoughts." - describing the extreme brain-to-body-mass ratio of giant sauropods.
- At 0:34:54 - "So what I will say about Dreadnoughtus is it's the most massive dinosaur for which we can confidently calculate a weight." - explaining how possessing both a humerus and a femur allowed a precise 65-ton mass calculation.
- At 0:42:20 - "We live in an age of giants now. The biggest animal to ever live is alive right now, right? The biggest trees to ever live are alive right now." - pointing out that modern blue whales and redwood trees surpass all prehistoric animals and plants in size.
- At 0:49:38 - "Think about that day: trillions upon trillions of millimeter-sized space capsules, each one flaming back into the atmosphere, each one heating up a little parcel of air around itself, such that we think that day, within an hour after the impact, temperatures got up somewhere between toaster oven and pizza oven." - describing the thermal mechanism that killed non-avian dinosaurs 66 million years ago.
- At 0:59:13 - "He figured out that we live on an old planet with a hammer and a rowboat." - crediting Scottish geologist James Hutton for discovering deep time at Siccar Point in 1795.
- At 1:01:56 - "When Darwin got on the HMS Beagle, he was a Young Earth creationist. He thought the Earth was 6,000 years old." - showing how Charles Lyell's geology transformed Darwin's worldview during his voyage.
- At 1:06:40 - "So he decides he's got to become an expert, so he takes nine years off from writing Origin of Species to become the world's expert on barnacles." - illustrating Darwin's meticulous effort to build scientific authority before publishing his theory of evolution.
- At 1:09:24 - "You'll rarely hear a scientist use the word 'prove,' right? What we say is 'we have failed to falsify,' right? Leaving the possibility open that it could be falsified in the future." - defining how the scientific method treats consensus and evidence.
- At 1:39:40 - "Mammoths were just here. I mean, the last mammoths went extinct about 3,000 years ago. Wrangel Island off Siberia. So 3,000 years ago, that's a world that has pyramids and written stories and beer, right?" - contextualizing how recently woolly mammoths shared the planet with human civilization.
- At 2:02:01 - "Cope challenged Marsh that, what he said, 'You know, when we die, let's donate our brains to science and see who has the bigger brain.' Like, that's the kind of a-holes these dudes were." - summarizing the personal pettiness driving the 19th-century Bone Wars.
Takeaways
- Consult a geological map before hunting for fossils so you can target exposed sedimentary rock layers of the right age—specifically between 237 million and 66 million years old if you want to find non-avian dinosaurs.
- Visit public excavation sites such as the Edelman Fossil Park & Museum in New Jersey (where Lacovara works and which he promotes during the episode) to experience digging in a 66-million-year-old mass mortality layer firsthand rather than taking paleontological claims on faith.
- Evaluate viral geological conspiracy theories—such as claims that flat-topped mountains like Wyoming's Devils Tower are giant petrified tree stumps—by checking basic igneous geology, which shows how slowly cooling volcanic lava fractures into hexagonal columnar basalt (also seen at the Hudson River Palisades and Ireland's Giant's Causeway).
- Separate pop-culture depictions from anatomical reality when viewing dinosaur media: remember that Michael Crichton modeled Jurassic Park's raptors on Deinonychus while using the name Velociraptor for dramatic effect, and that real Velociraptors had quill knobs on their ulnae proving they had feathers.
- Watch paleontological reconstructions like Apple TV's Prehistoric Planet with a critical eye by distinguishing hard osteological evidence from speculative soft-tissue additions, such as the unverified inflatable neck bladders added to Dreadnoughtus.
- Apply ecological population baselines when evaluating claims of massive cryptids like Bigfoot, the Loch Ness Monster, or the Congo's Mokele-mbembe: recognize that sustaining a breeding population requires roughly 1,000 individuals, which makes complete lack of physical evidence in modern habitats highly improbable compared to documented discoveries like the okapi or Congo's giant ground-nesting Bili apes.
- Frame scientific findings using the principle of falsifiability—asking whether a hypothesis has "failed to be falsified" rather than claiming absolute "proof"—to keep your thinking open to new evidence.
- Look for evolutionary links to prehistoric life in modern birds, such as the high-altitude respiratory efficiency of bar-headed geese flying over the Himalayas or the clawed wings found on newly hatched hoatzin ("stinkbird") chicks.
- Support intensive conservation breeding programs for critically endangered species, recognizing that targeted interventions like the San Diego Zoo's program successfully rebuilt the California condor population from just 22 individuals around 1970 to roughly 550 birds today.
- Distinguish between true permineralized fossils and "sub-fossils" (like those preserved in the La Brea Tar Pits, which retain original unmineralized bone material) when assessing the age and chemical preservation of ancient remains.
- Treat sensational molecular paleontology headlines—such as reports of 115-million-year-old dinosaur blood or catastrophic geomagnetic extinction events like the disputed "Adams Event"—with caution until independent experts verify the sampling methodology and cellular structures.
- Use historical perspective to appreciate modern biodiversity: recognize that because of the blue whale and coastal redwoods, we currently live alongside the largest animals and largest trees to ever exist in Earth's 4.567-billion-year history.