Andrew Scott | Good Hang with Amy Poehler
Audio Brief
Show transcript
When doctors told actor Ian Charleson that performing a four hour play could harm his health as he developed AIDS, Andrew Scott thinks Charleson replied that he would rather die of Hamlet than AIDS. On this November 17, 2026 episode of the Good Hang podcast, host Amy Poehler interviews Olivia Colman and Andrew Scott. By the end, you will learn how Scott brings observation, conversational rhythm, and protective humanity to his craft.
Looking outward unlocks authentic acting. Scott started acting at age 8 in a Flahavan's porridge commercial, despite personally disliking porridge, pudding, and soft foods that require no effort to eat. His art teacher mother taught him to look at the subject rather than the page, showing him that acting means seeing what the other person is actually doing rather than reacting to your own assumptions.
That focus on real human connection also changes how you handle classic texts, which helps rescue Shakespeare from the academics. Scott, who was never formally trained in Shakespeare, played the four hour Hamlet 150 times by comparing its rhythm to rap music and slowing down famous lines like "To be or not to be" so they sound like natural speech. Following director Rob Icke's philosophy that modern audiences happily binge multi hour TV box sets, Scott works to make the most annoying, inaccessible part of a play the most accessible part.
Making theater accessible also means recognizing why leaving jokes out of serious drama is bad manners. After performing in Henrik Ibsen's longest play at the National Theatre with zero jokes, Scott embraced actor Bill Nighy's rule that it is bad manners not to include humor in a play or film, because human beings instinctively make jokes when something terrible happens. At about age 22, Scott even broke into uncontrollable laughter on stage with Brian Cox after about six weeks of performances when stage management replaced stale prop biscuits with a 33 percent extra promo pack.
That same grounding in real human reactions reveals the unexpected kindness inside TV's most heartbreaking line. When he later played the Priest in Fleabag alongside creator Phoebe Waller-Bridge, whom he knew from a play about ten years earlier, many viewers thought his famous two word reply to "I love you" was cruel. Scott explains that saying "It'll pass" is actually humane and protective because the acute pain of heartbreak does eventually subside, and his character says he loves her too just a few minutes later.
Protective honesty also shapes the secret to portraying true loneliness on screen. In All of Us Strangers, shot over about four weeks in director Andrew Haigh's actual childhood home, Scott plays a man whose parents died when he was 12. Rather than playing loneliness as passive sadness, Scott notes that it is much sadder and more moving to show a person actively fighting loneliness and reaching for connection.
Just as reaching for connection transforms isolation, personal grief can fuel vital art. After his mother died a couple of years ago, Scott used the heavy energy of his grief to get his film Elsinore made. The movie tells the true 1989 story of Ian Charleson, who took on Hamlet after living with HIV for four years, forcing Scott to relearn the play from scratch because he forgets his lines as soon as a project ends.
Whether on stage or in life, truth comes from observing people as they really are, facing sorrow with humor, and meeting pain with honesty. "I'd rather die of Hamlet than AIDS."
Episode Overview
- Amy Poehler interviews Olivia Colman and Andrew Scott about Scott's upbringing in Dublin, his philosophy on making classical theater accessible, and his dramatic roles across stage and screen.
- The episode opens with a check-in with Olivia Colman, who shares her perspective on Scott's generous personality, artistic talents, and ability to make Shakespeare understandable.
- Scott traces his origins from childhood speech lessons for a lisp and youth drama competitions in Ireland to performing at the Abbey Theatre and navigating fame in his 30s.
- The conversation explores the craft of acting through Scott's iconic roles in Sherlock, Fleabag, and All of Us Strangers, emphasizing the importance of humor and humanity in tragic material.
- Scott details the true story behind his film Elsinore, explaining how personal grief after his mother's death fueled his portrayal of actor Ian Charleson's final performances of Hamlet.
Key Concepts
- Talent, Warmth, and Artistic Range (Promotions and Sponsors Context): While Andrew Scott is on the Good Hang podcast hosted by Amy Poehler to promote his new film Elsinore (costarring Olivia Colman, who also stars in an upcoming movie called Wicker), the episode includes sponsored ad reads by Poehler for PayPal (mentioning Pay in 4, Gap, Nordstrom, Target, and NMLS 910457), Visible by Verizon (mentioning Unlimited 5G data and hotspot starting at $19/month for a year with promo code HOLIDAYHACK), and eBay Live (mentioning live stream bidding on vintage Rolexes and rare Beanie Babies). In the pre-interview, Poehler states her theory that for the most part, the most talented people are usually the easiest to work with, and Colman agrees. Colman first saw Scott play the baddie [Moriarty] in Sherlock Holmes, and believes they first met on the set of Fleabag (hedging that he might come on and say they met 3 weeks before and she can't remember). Poehler contrasts Scott's warmth with doing scenes on Parks and Rec with Adam Scott, where she would ask him afterward if he was mad at her and he would reply, "No, I'm acting." Colman also notes that Andrew Scott is an amazing artist with impeccable interior design taste comparable to Ben Pentreath; Scott later confirms that in an alternate life he would work in drawing, painting, or design, describing himself as a bit of a minimalist who dislikes accumulating stuff and stainless steel because it is "printy."
- Observational Presence and Early Roots in Dublin: Great acting relies on outward observation rather than internal self-consciousness, a lesson Scott learned from his mother, an art teacher, while his father worked helping young people get jobs at an Irish company called FÁS (the Irish word for "growth"). Growing up as the middle child between two sisters, Scott's first acting job was a commercial for Flahavan's porridge ("Start the day the Flahavan's way") at 8 years old, though he personally dislikes porridge, pudding, rice pudding, and borderline dislikes risotto due to an issue with blended or soft foods that require no effort to eat (he also claims he is not a great cook and doesn't want to cook, though he likes chopping as a sous-chef). After starting speech and drama lessons at about age 9 to fix a bad lisp, Scott participated in May drama competitions called the Feis (the Irish word for festival), where 100 children in age brackets (under 10, under 12, under 14, and under 16) recited the same poem or Shakespeare extracts in a daytime hallway. Both Scott and Poehler performed in childhood productions of The Wizard of Oz (Scott played the Tin Man 40 years ago for 3 nights, and Poehler played Dorothy at age 9 or 10) and shared early ties to the Abbey Theatre (which Scott defines as the National Theatre of Ireland): Poehler attended Boston College and studied abroad in Dublin at the Abbey under Tomás Mac Anna for a 3-month semester in 1992 (hedging that she graduated in '93 so it must have been '92, and noting The Commitments had just come out and everything in Ireland was only 3 hours away), while Scott performed Eugene O'Neill's Long Day's Journey Into Night there as the son with consumption and recalls a friend paging him on a beeper at the theater in the pre-mobile phone 1990s.
- Reclaiming Shakespeare from Academics: Classical theater frequently alienates both audiences and actors when treated as an academic exercise rather than conversational speech. Olivia Colman admits she struggles with performing Shakespeare, hedging that she thinks she basically doesn't understand it and speeds up to get through it as fast as possible, though she claims Paul Mescal made it understandable in Hamnet. Similarly, Poehler credits Scott and actress Michelle Terry with helping her understand Shakespeare, specifically recalling how Scott slowed down "To be or not to be" in Hamlet. Having never been formally trained in Shakespeare, Scott approached his 150 performances of the 4-hour play by comparing its rhythm to rap music and adopting director Rob Icke's philosophy: because modern audiences happily binge multi-hour TV box sets, theater makers should take the most annoying, inaccessible part of a play and make it the most accessible part. Unlike Poehler, who has a tour rider from touring with Tina [Fey] requesting cut fruit, Scott notes theater actors do not have riders because theaters "don't care," joking that he has played two sell-out stadiums.
- The "Bad Manners" of Humorless Drama: Stripping humor out of serious storytelling is unnatural because human beings instinctively use jokes to cope with tragedy. After performing in Henrik Ibsen's longest play (Emperor and Galilean) at the National Theatre with zero jokes, Scott embraced actor Bill Nighy's rule that it is "bad manners" not to include humor in a play or film. Scott actively seeks out humor in daily life: to make himself laugh, he watches a viral video on his phone of an elderly Irish couple giggling uncontrollably while sending a message to their daughter Orla (hedging that he thinks it's a christening). He also recalls breaking into uncontrollable laughter on stage at about age 22 in an Irish play at the Royal Court with Brian Cox after about 6 weeks of performances, when stage management replaced stale prop biscuits with a "33% extra" promo pack (speculating there must have been a deal on the biscuits), causing Cox to pause mid-line ("Do you want a biscuit?") to stare at the giant biscuits.
- Humane Realism in Fame and Heartbreak (Sherlock and Fleabag): Experiencing public scrutiny only once he was in his 30s allowed Scott to separate the craft of acting from the pursuit of celebrity. For instance, he did not enjoy watching himself play Moriarty alongside Benedict Cumberbatch in Sherlock. When he later joined Fleabag (having already known creator Phoebe Waller-Bridge from being in a play together about 10 years previously), he brought deep emotional realism to the "Hot Priest." While many viewers interpret his character's response to "I love you" ("It'll pass") as cruel, Scott explains that it is actually humane and protective because the acute pain of heartbreak does eventually subside, and he reminds listeners that his character tells her he loves her too just a few minutes later.
- Depicting Loneliness and Generational Progress (All of Us Strangers): In All of Us Strangers, which stars just 4 actors (Scott, Claire Foy, Jamie Bell, and Paul Mescal), Scott plays a man whose parents died when he was 12; the film was shot over about 4 weeks in director Andrew Haigh's actual childhood home, with Scott spending the first couple of weeks filming with Bell and Foy. Rather than playing loneliness as passive sadness, Scott notes that loneliness is most movingly depicted by showing a person actively fighting it and reaching for connection. Discussing the film's themes of queer isolation, both Scott and Poehler note they had zero openly gay kids, parents, or teachers in their classes growing up, making Ireland becoming the first country in the world to legalize gay marriage by public referendum one of the happiest days of Scott's life. This vulnerability also connects to what moves them as audience members: Scott cried during the first 20 minutes of the Pixar movie Up on an airplane and names Dead Man Walking with Sean Penn and Susan Sarandon as a movie that makes him cry, while Poehler names Terms of Endearment (and later in the outro explains the 1980s TV show Dallas as their generation's Yellowstone, noting Larry Hagman played J.R. Ewing in the "Who shot J.R.?" cliffhanger that dominated People magazine covers when there were only 3 channels).
- Channeling Grief into Art (Elsinore): Personal loss can generate a vital energy that compels artists to tell stories about mortality and dedication. Scott experienced this after his mother died a couple of years ago, using the energy of his grief to get his film Elsinore made. The film tells the true 1989 story of respected actor Ian Charleson (known for Chariots of Fire and Gandhi), who took over the role of Hamlet after living with HIV for 4 years and developing AIDS almost simultaneously with taking the part. Although doctors advised Charleson that waiting a couple of years for developing HIV treatments could buy him time whereas performing a 4-hour play would harm his health, Charleson chose to perform, stating (as Scott hedges he thinks Charleson said), "I'd rather die of Hamlet than AIDS." Because Scott forgets his lines as soon as a project ends, he had to relearn Hamlet for the film, and he was glad no footage of Charleson's performance existed so he would not copy it.
Quotes
- At 0:03:34 - "Oh, he makes you feel like you're the funniest person alive and you're the only person in the room, but I know that he's managing to do that for 15 people at the same time." - Olivia Colman describing Andrew Scott's warmth and presence on set.
- At 0:15:19 - "Well, I started acting because I had quite a bad lisp when I was a kid. Yes, which is cute for a while, and then sort of when I was about nine, they were like, maybe we should do something about this. So I went to speech and drama lessons." - Andrew Scott explaining the unexpected childhood speech impediment that launched his acting career.
- At 0:18:13 - "And she was so right, and that's how it links to acting in some ways, that you have to be seeing what the person is doing rather than what you think they're doing." - Andrew Scott connecting his art-teacher mother's advice on looking at the subject while drawing to listening in acting.
- At 0:29:40 - "Well, it's sort of like being in a minor car accident. You know, where you think, what happened? I was definitely—you're sort of like..." - Andrew Scott describing the disorienting adrenaline and nervousness that follows a live stage performance.
- At 0:37:01 - "Because the idea—I never equated, necessarily, success as an actor with being famous. I really genuinely didn't." - Andrew Scott reflecting on his early theater career in Dublin and expressing gratitude for not experiencing fame until his 30s.
- At 0:40:05 - "And Bill Nighy, the great actor, he says—and he's right—that it's bad manners not to have any jokes in a play or a film. Because it's not reflective of the way human beings are. Human beings, when something terrible happens, we make a joke." - Andrew Scott explaining why even the heaviest tragedies require moments of levity.
- At 0:41:34 - "Because I do think Shakespeare has been kidnapped by academics, genuinely. There are 300 books written about how you should say it, iambic pentameter, which I still don't understand what that is. I do not know. I played Hamlet 150 times, I'm still like, what?" - Andrew Scott arguing for a conversational, accessible approach to classical theater.
- At 0:45:50 - "And she says, 'I love you,' and he says, 'It'll pass.' Which could be construed as quite a cruel thing to say potentially, but actually I think it's incredibly humane. Because it does pass. It may not pass entirely, but that horrible feeling like that we've all been through, you know, it subsides a little bit." - Andrew Scott defending the humanity behind his famous line in Fleabag.
- At 0:50:15 - "Again, I think that's about like reaching for—I think, you know, it's trying not to be lonely that is much sadder." - Andrew Scott explaining how to portray loneliness without clichés in All of Us Strangers.
- At 0:54:51 - "Well, we had in Ireland, was the first country in the world to vote in gay marriage by a referendum, so meaning the public voted for it, and genuinely, you know, rather than just them passing a law to modernize the laws. And genuinely, that was one of the happiest days of my life." - Andrew Scott discussing the emotional impact of public acceptance after growing up without openly queer role models.
- At 0:57:44 - "What I find kind of moving about it is that he sort of nailed his colors to the mast in the end. He was like, 'I'm an actor, and that's how I'm going to—even if it kills me.' He says, 'I'd rather die of Hamlet than AIDS.'" - Andrew Scott recounting the true story of actor Ian Charleson that inspired the film Elsinore (hedging at 0:57:51 that he thinks that is what Charleson said).
- At 1:00:47 - "My mom died a couple of years ago, and I was really, you know, still am, carrying a huge amount of grief. But there's a kind of energy that grief gives you, I think, which is like, I know this story." - Andrew Scott sharing how mourning his mother gave him the drive to bring Elsinore to the screen.
Takeaways
- Practice active observation in conversations and creative work by focusing outward on what the other person is actually doing in the moment, rather than looking down at your own "page" or reacting to your assumptions.
- Incorporate humor when communicating heavy or tragic themes, recognizing that levity is not a distraction from seriousness but an authentic reflection of how human beings cope and connect.
- Demystify complex or intimidating material by stripping away academic jargon and focusing on conversational rhythm and meaning, slowing down famous or dense passages so the audience can genuinely understand them.
- Reframe how you confront difficult blocks in a project by taking the most inaccessible, annoying, or intimidating section and deliberately working to make it the most engaging and accessible part.
- Separate your definition of professional success from public fame or external validation so you can focus on longevity and craft without becoming overly self-conscious.
- Express challenging emotional truths with protective humanity rather than avoiding them, remembering that acknowledging painful realities ("It'll pass") can be a generous way to comfort someone in distress.
- Channel the heavy emotional energy of personal grief into purposeful creative or personal projects that honor human resilience and shared experiences of loss.