Alanis Morissette (Live) | Good Hang with Amy Poehler

Good Hang with Amy Poehler Good Hang with Amy Poehler • Nov 03, 2026

Audio Brief

Show transcript
Can sitting in silent meditation actually be dangerous if you are in the midst of trauma? Alanis Morissette argues it can be. In this November 3, 2026 episode of the Good Hang podcast, host Amy Poehler sits down at a live Chicago recording with Morissette. By the end, you will learn how to rethink anger, shyness, relationships, and the pursuit of wholeness. Why chasing wholeness beats chasing wellness, and when meditation can backfire. Morissette argues that meditation is overrated and can be dangerous for people in the midst of trauma, though she notes it is not dangerous for everybody and can be bliss for some. She separates wellness, an outward, patriarchal push toward self improvement that ignores our dark parts, from wholeness, which is coming home to who you already are without needing to be fixed. Instead, she uses Internal Family Systems, a therapy that treats the mind as a collection of distinct inner parts, to manage the thousands of parts in her head when about 12 want attention at once. When you are stopped at a red light, try a 13 second check in with one or two anxious inner parts by asking what they need from you and what wisdom they have. How to separate healthy anger from destructive acting out. When Morissette was 19 and making her album Jagged Little Pill with Glen Ballard, record executives resisted releasing You Oughta Know as the first single because they felt female anger was too harsh. Morissette insisted on starting on that exact note, explaining that people confuse violent acting out, like using guns or knives, with anger itself. Real anger is a healthy current signaling a crossed boundary. Use your own anger as a signal that one of four core boundaries was crossed: someone touching your belongings, telling you what you feel, telling you what you think, or touching your body without permission. Why your clingiest survival response and your shyness are actually protecting you. Of the five trauma responses, fight, flight, freeze, collapse, and the people pleasing response known as fawn, people often criticize fawning as clingy or needy. Morissette defends her own fawn response because it is the only one of the five that is relational and reaches for human connection. She also questions whether shyness is real after her idol Annie Lennox politely brushed her off at the Brit Awards, calling shyness a nervous system pause to check if someone is safe. Stop trying to erase your baseline nerves or hesitation, and instead honor shyness as a normal pause to check if a new person or room is safe. Trading fierce independence for healing together in long term love. During the show, superfan Kelly Kroyer asks which song has changed meaning for the singer. Morissette chooses Not the Doctor. She explains that she has outgrown the song's youthful attitude of telling a partner to fix their own problems alone before talking, and now believes committed partners should actively participate in each other's healing. In your own committed relationships, move past rigid independence by actively helping your partner heal. How early rejection and comedic intelligence fuel creative resilience. Growing up in Ottawa, producers on the sketch show You Can't Do That on Television cut Morissette's audition short for being too tall before chasing her out of the building to bring her back. She calls comedy the number one intelligence, even above music, and treats creative collaboration as a place where one plus one equals 14. Remember that psychological wholeness is not about fixing yourself, whether you are talking to your inner parts or running marathons for an eating disorder charity the way Morissette did to honor her body. This is an instrument, this is not just an ornament.

Episode Overview

  • Amy Poehler hosts a live Chicago recording with musical guest Amy Miles, superfan Kelly Kroyer, and main guest Alanis Morissette to discuss Morissette's path from child performer and teenage rock icon to her current views on anger, fame, trauma, and psychological wholeness.
  • The show opens with theme music by Amy Miles and a conversation with Chicago native Kelly Kroyer about her career in hospitality and how Morissette's music shaped her youth.
  • Morissette reflects on her early career in Ottawa, starting a record label in childhood, and the creation of Jagged Little Pill, including her push to lead with female anger and her bond with drummer Taylor Hawkins.
  • The discussion explores psychological frameworks, examining why wholeness is preferable to wellness, how Internal Family Systems parts work functions, and why meditation can carry risks for trauma survivors.
  • The episode concludes with Morissette discussing her Christmas album, how long-term marriage changed her perspective on her earlier songwriting, and a lightning round covering her Canadian roots, marathon running, and family life.

Key Concepts

  • Wholeness vs. Wellness and the Risks of Meditation: On the Good Hang podcast (produced by Spotify, The Ringer, and Paper Kite Productions, and sponsored by presenting sponsor PayPal and episode sponsor Subaru), Morissette distinguishes between "wellness" and "wholeness." She frames wellness as a patriarchal, outward push toward self-improvement that ignores dark or shadow parts, whereas wholeness is about coming home to who you already are without needing to be fixed. In this context, she argues that meditation is overrated and can be dangerous for those in the midst of trauma, though she hedges that it is not dangerous for everybody and can be bliss for some. Citing trauma expert Peter Levine, she hedges that he calls it something like anxiety or "meditation-induced anxiety," which happens when silence leaves trauma survivors alone with mean internal protective voices before they have developed adequate internal resources. Instead, she practices Internal Family Systems parts work to manage the "thousands" of parts in her head (often with "about 12 parts" seeking attention at once), noting that on the Enneagram she is a 4 with a 5 wing (having previously thought she had a 3 wing due to public achievement), while her daughter is an 8 and Poehler is an 8 with a 9 wing ("the bear").
  • Healthy Anger vs. Destructive Acting Out: When making Jagged Little Pill with Glen Ballard at age 19 (correcting Poehler's statement that she was 21), record executives resisted releasing "You Oughta Know" as the first single because they felt female anger was too harsh, whereas Morissette insisted on starting on that exact note. She explains that people confuse destructive acting out (like violence with guns or knives) with anger itself, which is a healthy emotional current that signals a boundary violation. Relatedly, she notes that as women approach menopause and progesterone and other hormones drop to zero, the "scaffolding of cotton balls and cozy tolerance" from their procreative years disappears; she cites a book she calls Shakti Woman to claim that historical communities sought out PMSing women to lead town halls and tell the city what needed to be done.
  • Reframing Survival Strategies, Temperament, and Shyness: Morissette outlines five trauma survival strategies (fight, flight, freeze, collapse, and befriend/appease/fawn) and defends her own fawn response against criticism that it is "clingy" or "needy," pointing out that it is the only strategy of the five that is relational and reaches for human connection. She also reframes other psychological traits: she suggests people who self-diagnose with ADHD (hedging that they "may well" have it) might simply be born with "overexcitable cognition" (or "excitable cognition"), and she questions whether shyness is real, defining it instead as a nervous system safety check after recounting how her idol Annie Lennox politely brushed her off ("Alanis, nice to meet you, lovely work you're doing") at the Brit Awards. Furthermore, she accepts that lifelong performance nerves cannot be eliminated because temperament is fixed, contrasting her outward "black stallion" persona with her internal "scared tiny shaky poodle" temperament, and noting she uses her long, product-free, never-blow-dried hair (maintained only with an overpriced brush, though she once nearly shaved it) as an onstage security blanket that does "the job of fem for me, because I like to dress like a 14-year-old boy."
  • Evolving From Hyper-Independence to Relational Healing: In the opening segments, musical guest Amy Miles (accompanied by Chris Anderson on drums) clarifies that a rumor that Amy Poehler sang the Good Hang theme song is false and that Miles is the singer, before instructing the crowd to clap 16 times really fast for the intro (hedging afterward that she doesn't know if that was 16, it sounded right). Poehler welcomes the crowd to the 2:00 p.m. live show (noting it will end before 4:00 so attendees can do two cultural things in one day and be in their pajamas by 6:00), reminisces about starting her unpaid comedy career in Chicago while working at a restaurant called Carlucci's that she claims had "a lot of cocaine" (not in the food), and mentions fan mail responses while hedging that they got a lot and she should know the number. Poehler then interviews 42-year-old superfan and stay-at-home mom Kelly Kroyer, whose parents were both Chicago police officers (her mother worked two careers, first as a flight attendant), who takes the CTA train about 45 minutes door to door from near O'Hare Airport, and who worked a 22-year hotel hospitality career after walking up and down River Road by O'Hare to land a front desk job after college (where a male guest once insisted engineering put a board under his mattress to make it harder, though Kroyer hedges she can't remember if he paid extra, adding he should have). Kroyer shares that hearing Morissette on the radio in 1998 as a high school freshman guided her through the next four years (with "Uninvited" as her favorite song) and that she saw Morissette live about 15 years ago at Ravinia (hedging that she can't remember who the opener was or most of yesterday, though there might have been a really nice opener). When Kroyer asks which song has changed meaning for her, Morissette picks "Not the Doctor," explaining that she has evolved from the song's youthful stance ("you take care of your stuff and we'll talk") to believing that committed partners should actively participate in each other's healing.
  • Creative Resilience, Comedy as Intelligence, and Collaborative Relief: Tracing her path from Ottawa, Canada (which she notes has been called Chicago's sister city), Morissette recalls her brothers saying she "couldn't sing my way out of a paper bag" before family friend Lindsay Morgan prepared a backing track for her cassette tape, leading her to start her own record label at age 10 or 11 because labels weren't signing children. She also recounts auditioning for the Canadian sketch show You Can't Do That on Television, where producers dismissed her halfway through for being "too tall" before chasing her out of the building to bring her back. Morissette argues that comedy, even more than music, is the "number one" intelligence. She reflects on her love of comedy and creative collaboration: watching every episode of Three's Company 19 times and sitting too nervously to speak next to John Ritter on an LA exercise bike before he warmly greeted her by name for coffee years later at a movie theater Starbucks; writing about 25 songs per album to pick "12-ish"; touring with Radiohead (who opened for her in the 1990s) and Joan Jett; and auditioning drummer Taylor Hawkins at age 20, who became an "instant soul brother" offering constant kindness and validation until right before his death. Today, while actively promoting her upcoming Christmas/holiday album (inspired by her son being born on Christmas morning after she previously never cared about the holiday, and following a few years of recording one Christmas song annually), she celebrates collaborations with Brandi Carlile, Steve Martin on banjo (fulfilling a promise made to herself at age 22), and Martin Short (with whom she shares a Judy Garland obsession and hopes to recreate a Garland video frame-by-frame), while finding daily comic relief in comedian Patty Guggenheim and the intimacy of creative collaboration ("where 1 + 1 = 14").

Quotes

  • At 0:24:19 - "It's just every stone, everything: identity, service, value systems, relationships, who is God, how to talk to these parts, these billions of parts in here, you know, be responsible for what this is and not make it everyone else's problem." - Morissette explaining the comprehensive nature of her internal psychological and spiritual self-inquiry.
  • At 0:25:19 - "Then you get closer to menopause and progesterone, all the hormones are at zero, so all the sort of scaffolding of cotton balls and cozy tolerance, they go away." - Morissette describing how hormonal shifts around menopause strip away women's conditioned tolerance.
  • At 0:32:01 - "I mean, the temperament I have is like a scared tiny shaky poodle, but my outward-facing situation is often a black stallion, so they're at odds a lot." - Morissette contrasting her sensitive internal temperament with her bold public persona.
  • At 0:35:51 - "So I think the wave of feminism was happening with or without any of us, really, and I just volunteered to get on the top of the wave, and then I was there, and I was being credited for things that may or may not have been appropriate to credit me for, but what I was happy to do was be at the epicenter of it, and I was happy to be on the front and get my head chopped off." - Morissette reflecting on her role at the forefront of 1990s feminism during the Jagged Little Pill era.
  • At 0:37:03 - "Fame is a giant screen upon which people project all their beautiful stuff to define themselves in accordance to you." - Morissette defining the psychological dynamic between famous artists and their audiences.
  • At 0:39:40 - "I'm talking about anger itself, the beautiful current that courses through you when it's appropriate, there's been a boundary transgressed: you can't touch my stuff, you can't tell me what I'm feeling, you can't tell me what I'm thinking, and you cannot touch my body without permission." - Morissette distinguishing healthy anger as a boundary-protecting signal from destructive violence.
  • At 0:41:37 - "I'm particularly upset about the fact that fawn is the one that gets the bad rap, people are like, 'Ooh, clingy, needy,' I'm like, it's of the five survival strategies, it's the only one that's relational, it's the only one that reaches for connection." - Morissette defending the appeasement or fawn trauma response as a connection-seeking survival strategy.
  • At 0:49:57 - "So I think the movement toward better, wellness, is this way; wholeness is coming home, totally different direction, there's nothing to add, you don't need to be fixed, it's just remembering who you are and being in environments where people will reflect you accurately enough, just enough, that you're there." - Morissette contrasting the endless self-improvement of wellness with the self-acceptance of wholeness.
  • At 0:51:04 - "Well, for those of us who are in the midst of trauma, or a traumatic experience that we're perhaps on the verge of beginning to heal, meditating is actually quite dangerous because you're left alone with all these protective voices who are attempting to protect you, God bless, but they can be really mean." - Morissette explaining why silent meditation can harm unresourced trauma survivors.
  • At 0:53:11 - "Or I'll say, you know, 'What do you need from me? What action can I take on your behalf? What wisdom do you have for me? What am I not seeing here?' And often they'll tell me." - Morissette sharing the specific questions she uses to dialogue with her internal parts.
  • At 1:01:07 - "Shy is just pausing to check if the person is safe." - Morissette reframing shyness as an adaptive nervous system assessment rather than a personality flaw.
  • At 1:04:33 - "I did it as a way of saying this is an instrument, this is not just an ornament." - Morissette explaining why she ran marathons for charities like the National Eating Disorders Association (NEDA).

Takeaways

  • Practice a "13-second" internal check-in (such as when stopped at a red light) by asking one or two anxious internal parts at a time, "What do you need from me? What action can I take on your behalf? What wisdom do you have for me?" while asking the other parts to wait beside you.
  • Use feelings of anger as a diagnostic signal that one of four core boundaries has been crossed: someone touching your belongings, telling you what you feel, telling you what you think, or touching your body without permission.
  • Approach silent meditation with caution if you are actively healing from trauma; instead of sitting alone with harsh internal protective voices, build psychological resources and place yourself in environments where safe people reflect you accurately.
  • Treat your body as a functional instrument rather than a decorative ornament by engaging in physical goals for causes you care about, drawing on Morissette's example of running marathons for NEDA (where she savored mile 20 to the finish and weeping in cold water afterward, even if she won't run one again).
  • Stop trying to eliminate performance nerves or natural social hesitation; accept that your baseline temperament is with you for life, and honor moments of "shyness" as a normal pause to verify whether a new person or environment is safe, including cultural habits like waiting to be asked a question before speaking (as Morissette notes she didn't speak for 6 months after moving to LA waiting to be asked a question, hedging that she doesn't know if the whole country of Canada does this).
  • Move beyond hyper-independent boundary setting in committed long-term relationships by actively participating in your partner's healing rather than insisting they resolve all their issues alone before engaging with you.
  • Cultivate varied sources of joy, musical discovery, and low-stakes connection in daily life, whether listening to tracks recommended by your kids (like Steve Lacy) or personal favorites (like Keane's "Hamburg Song"), sharing quiet companionship like Morissette's "straight telepathy" with her twin brother Wade around campfires, or grabbing a simple comfort treat like sugary and chocolate Tim Hortons "Munchkins" (Timbits).