The Hard Part Isn’t Buying Trend Following | Systematic Investor | Ep.426
Audio Brief
Show transcript
SUMMARY:
SUMMARY:
Why do traditional investment portfolios fall apart exactly when you need them most? Institutional investment experts reveal how standard diversification is often an illusion, showing how trend following strategies, known as CTAs, can protect your wealth. On this episode, these experts break down the mechanics of portfolio defense. By the end, you will learn how to build a resilient, crisis proof portfolio.
Safeguard your wealth when markets tumble.
Most assets, from private equity to credit, actually plummet together when stock markets crash. True protection requires convexity, which is a structural feature that delivers positive returns during a decline. Think of it like buying a protective options overlay, capturing market gains while limiting or reversing your losses when things go bad. Look beyond superficial capital allocations and assess your portfolio based on actual risk allocation.
The two distinct paths to portfolio protection.
Portfolio safety can happen naturally or mechanically, and the difference is crucial. Return convexity happens automatically, like when bonds rise as equities fall in times of low inflation. Exposure convexity is an active, mechanical shift where a trend following manager dynamically shorts equities as a market downturn develops. Account for the transition lag in trend following strategies, recognizing that shifting from long to short positions takes time after an extended equity rally.
Dynamic risk balancing beats fixed allocation.
A standard sixty forty portfolio holds a hidden danger, as high volatility stocks quietly dominate lower volatility bonds. CTAs solve this by equalizing risk across asset classes rather than just balancing dollars. They dynamically deleverage high risk equities and leverage up low volatility bonds to generate defensive crisis returns. Maximize your capital efficiency by allocating to multi asset or bond heavy trend strategies rather than capital intensive, equity only programs.
Why equity trends cannot save you in a sudden crash.
When a sudden crisis strikes, the equity portion of a trend strategy is historically too late to the party. Trend models are far more efficient at capturing bond trends than equity trends. This means a CTA's historical protection during stock market crashes is actually driven by its bond and commodity exposures, not immediate short equity positions.
High inflation breaks traditional diversification.
The classic defensive relationship of a balanced portfolio completely relies on low inflation. When inflation climbs past four to five percent, bonds and equities become positively correlated and crash together, just as they did in twenty twenty two. To survive this, you need commodity trend following to maintain your defense. Incorporate commodity trend following into your asset allocation to serve as an inflation hedge when bonds and equities fall together.
Match your strategy speed to the threat.
Fast reacting models can protect against sudden shocks. Fast models react rapidly but hold less exposure to sustained trends, while slow models experience a lag during sudden turns but build massive defensive positions during prolonged, multi quarter crises. Align the speed of your trend following models with the specific threats you anticipate, using faster models for abrupt shocks and slower models for prolonged macroeconomic crises.
Genuine diversification requires raw materials.
Commodities share only a twenty to thirty percent correlation with standard trend following portfolios, offering genuine protection against inflation shocks. In contrast, alternative market CTAs share a seventy to eighty percent correlation, offering very little extra benefit. Prioritize allocations to commodity specific trend strategies over generalized alternative market CTAs.
Avoid the destructive behavior of buying CTA funds after strong performance and selling them during drawdowns. Protect your wealth by matching your strategy speed to the threat, and remember that a bond and commodity trend gives you essentially inflation plus a constant number.
Episode Overview
- Institutional investment experts discuss the mechanics of trend-following strategies (CTAs), how they generate "convexity" to protect portfolios during market downturns, and the critical structural differences between equity and bond trend protection.
- The conversation frames the narrative of portfolio defense, moving from the illusion of diversification in private markets to the specific macro conditions under which bonds, commodities, and CTAs successfully mitigate risk.
- This content is highly relevant to institutional allocators, portfolio managers, and sophisticated investors seeking to construct resilient, all-weather portfolios that can withstand inflation shocks, equity crashes, and shifting correlation regimes.
Key Concepts
- Understanding Convexity in Investing: Convexity refers to an investment's structural ability to deliver positive returns when equity markets decline, behaving similarly to a protective options overlay by capturing upside while limiting or reversing downside exposure.
- Return Convexity vs. Exposure Convexity: Return convexity occurs when asset classes naturally move in opposite directions (e.g., bonds rising when equities fall in low-inflation environments), whereas exposure convexity is the mechanical, trend-following adjustment of portfolio positioning (e.g., a CTA shorting equities as a downturn develops).
- The Role of CTAs in Portfolio Protection: CTAs act as capital-efficient risk allocators that dynamically size positions, equalizing risk across asset classes by deleveraging high-volatility equities and leveraging low-volatility bonds to generate defensive "crisis alpha."
- Asymmetry in Asset-Class Convexity: CTAs do not treat all assets equally; they are far more capital-efficient at capturing bond trends than equity trends, meaning a CTA's historical protection during equity crashes is often driven by its bond and commodity exposures rather than immediate short-equity positions.
- Inflation Regimes and Bond-Equity Correlation: The traditional defensive relationship of a 60/40 portfolio relies on low inflation; when inflation exceeds 4% to 5%, bonds and equities become positively correlated and decline together, necessitating commodity trend-following to maintain portfolio defense.
- Convexity vs. Responsiveness in Trend Speed: Fast trend-following models react rapidly to market shocks but carry lower average exposure to sustained trends, while slow trend-following models experience a lag during sudden turns but build larger, more committed defensive positions during prolonged, multi-quarter crises.
- Diversification Efficiency of Commodity Trend: Commodities possess a low correlation (20% to 30%) to standard liquid CTA portfolios, offering significant diversification and protecting against inflation shocks, whereas alternative market CTAs exhibit high correlations (70% to 80%) and provide diminishing marginal utility.
Quotes
- At 0:12:14 - "Convexity is something nicer... It's a little bit like buying an option. It makes money both on the upside and on the downside." - Explaining the fundamental appeal of convexity as a risk-mitigation tool that behaves similarly to an options overlay.
- At 0:13:30 - "A lot of the assets that you have, whether they are private equity, private credit, public credit... a lot of that are actually very positively correlated to equity. So that means that if equity goes down 5%, they will tend to go on average down as well." - Highlighting the hidden correlation risk in traditional diversified portfolios and why true convex strategies are needed.
- At 0:16:09 - "There is something like exposure convexity... when equity goes down, we will short equity in the same asset class. We will tend to become over time short that position." - Distinguishing how CTAs generate convexity through active trend-following and shorting rather than just passive holding.
- At 0:17:44 - "A CTA which holds an allocation to equity... will go short equity, but it will take time to actually build up this position because a drawdown by definition comes after a big equity rally." - Explaining the lag effect in trend-following strategies during sudden market turns.
- At 0:20:25 - "In the real market, people invest dollars... If you have a 60/40 allocation to equities and bonds, your risk allocation to equity is much higher because equity is [higher] volatility... whereas bonds are lower volatility... your 40% allocation to bonds doesn't actually have as much risk as your 60% allocation to equities." - Explaining why a simple capital allocation does not equal risk allocation, and why CTAs seek to balance risk rather than capital.
- At 0:21:13 - "CTAs basically try to get equal risk in each asset class... What they will do is they will actually delever their position in equity and lever up the exposure in bonds." - Clarifying the mechanical adjustments CTAs make to achieve risk parity across different asset classes.
- At 0:27:55 - "When inflation is low, bonds will perform well, the correlation is negative, and they assist you in an equity drawdown. But when inflation is high... when equity goes down, bond goes down as well. And we saw that in 2022." - Explaining the breakdown of the traditional 60/40 portfolio defensive characteristics during stagflationary or high-inflation environments.
- At 0:31:16 - "When we see a sharp crisis, the equity part of the convexity actually is just too late to the party... and most of the convexity you are getting is actually from the first responder, from the bond portfolio." - Revealing that in sudden market shocks, equity trend models cannot react fast enough, leaving bond trend models to do the heavy lifting of portfolio defense.
- At 0:34:38 - "We would have liked equity to be a first responder to bonds, and bonds to be a first responder to equities, but there is an asymmetry here... Equities historically offer very little bond convexity." - Highlights the structural asymmetry where bond trends protect equities, but equity trends do not historically protect bonds during bond bear markets.
- At 0:43:39 - "Equities are a growth game... it's inflation plus something which varies with growth, whereas a bond plus commodity trend gives you essentially inflation plus a constant number." - Explains why bonds and commodities are cleaner systemic protectors against inflation than growth-dependent equities.
- At 1:01:15 - "The way that people tend to invest in trend following is basically trend following trend following... they look at performance and the flows reflect a trend-following behavior... which is very destructive from an investor's perspective." - Explaining why chasing past performance in CTA allocations leads to suboptimal investor outcomes.
Takeaways
- Look beyond superficial capital allocations and assess your portfolio based on risk allocation, recognizing that traditional equity risk often heavily dominates bond risk in standard balanced portfolios.
- Account for the transition lag in trend-following strategies during market turning points, recognizing that exposure convexity requires time to shift from long to short positions after extended equity rallies.
- Incorporate commodity trend-following into your asset allocation to serve as an inflation hedge and preserve portfolio convexity when bonds and equities become positively correlated.
- Align the speed of your trend-following models with the specific threats you anticipate, using faster models for abrupt, short-term shocks and slower models for prolonged macroeconomic crises.
- Maximize capital efficiency by allocating to multi-asset or bond-heavy trend strategies rather than capital-intensive, equity-only trend programs.
- Prioritize allocations to commodity-specific trend strategies over generalized alternative market CTAs to achieve genuine diversification and a higher marginal Sharpe ratio.
- Avoid the destructive behavior of "trend following on trend following," which involves buying CTA funds after periods of strong performance and selling them during drawdown periods.