Consciousness: fundamental to reality? | Philip Goff
Audio Brief
Show transcript
Can the tiniest subatomic particles in the universe actually feel things? Philosopher Philip Goff argues they can, defending the controversial theory of panpsychism against skeptical theoretical physicists. In this talk, Goff explores how this radical framework might guide the future of consciousness science. You will learn how this philosophical framework can guide the future of consciousness science.
Philip Goff explains that consciousness is a fundamental and ubiquitous feature of our physical world. This means even basic particles like electrons have incredibly simple forms of experience. Under this view, the very complex experience of the human or animal brain is somehow derived from the very simple experience of the brain's most basic parts.
Physical properties are actually forms of consciousness.
Mass, spin, and charge are not separate from consciousness. This view, inspired by Bertrand Russell, holds that these standard physical properties are actually intrinsic forms of consciousness. Instead of thinking of physical matter and conscious experience as two different things, the Russellian panpsychist believes that the physical properties of mass, spin, and charge are themselves forms of consciousness.
Physics tells us what matter does, not what it is.
Physics excels at describing how matter behaves and interacts, but when you look at the information we get from physics, it is really all about behavior. It remains silent on the intrinsic nature of what matter actually is, leaving a conceptual gap that panpsychism attempts to fill.
How simple experiences build a human mind.
Weak emergentism views human consciousness as a collective result of simple conscious particles. In contrast, strong emergentism suggests that entirely new, fundamental conscious properties emerge at the complex level of the brain. This means the established physical laws of the Core Theory are perfectly correct on their own terms, but for the strong emergentist, those properties are not the only things running the show.
The invisible nature of our inner lives.
Because consciousness is not publicly observable, scientists must rely on controversial detection principles, such as self reporting. This complicates the search for neural correlates of consciousness.
Remember to look to neuroscience rather than fundamental physics to find empirical evidence for or against the emergence of consciousness in complex systems. We can identify gaps in purely physicalist explanations of reality by distinguishing between the behavioral properties and the intrinsic properties of matter.
Episode Overview
- Philosopher Philip Goff defends panpsychism against criticisms from theoretical physicists and outlines how this philosophical framework can guide the future of consciousness science.
- The talk clarifies the distinction between dualist panpsychism and Russellian panpsychism, arguing that physical properties are themselves forms of consciousness.
- Goff categorizes panpsychism into weak and strong emergentist views, explaining how they interact with established physical laws like the Core Theory.
- The presentation addresses the limitations of purely behavior-based physics and the challenges of locating consciousness in the brain through neuroscience.
Key Concepts
- Panpsychism: This theory proposes that consciousness is a fundamental and ubiquitous feature of the physical world, suggesting that even basic particles like electrons have incredibly simple forms of experience.
- Russellian Panpsychism: Inspired by Bertrand Russell, this view holds that physical properties like mass, spin, and charge are not separate from consciousness, but are actually intrinsic forms of consciousness.
- The Limit of Physics: Physics excels at describing how matter behaves and interacts, but it remains silent on the intrinsic nature of what matter actually is, leaving a conceptual gap that panpsychism attempts to fill.
- Weak vs. Strong Emergentism: Weak emergentism views human consciousness as a collective result of simple conscious particles, whereas strong emergentism suggests that entirely new, fundamental conscious properties emerge at the complex level of the brain.
- The Observability Problem: Because consciousness is not publicly observable, scientists must rely on controversial detection principles, such as self-reporting, which complicates the search for neural correlates of consciousness.
Quotes
- At 0:20 - "and that the very complex experience of the human or animal brain is somehow derived from the very simple experience of the brain's most basic parts." - explaining the core premise of how panpsychism accounts for complex human minds.
- At 4:36 - "The view of the Russellian panpsychist is that the physical properties of mass, spin, and charge are forms of consciousness." - clarifying a common misconception about the relationship between physical properties and consciousness.
- At 5:13 - "when you actually look at the information we're getting from physics, it's really all about what stuff does; it's about behavior." - highlighting the limitation of physical science in explaining the intrinsic nature of matter.
- At 14:24 - "The core theory is perfectly correct on its own terms... but for the strong emergentist, it's not just those properties running the show." - explaining how strong emergentism can coexist with established physical laws without violating them.
Takeaways
- Distinguish between weak and strong emergentism when evaluating theories of mind to understand whether consciousness is reductive or introduces new fundamental laws.
- Use the distinction between behavioral properties and intrinsic properties to identify gaps in purely physicalist explanations of reality.
- Look to neuroscience rather than fundamental physics to find empirical evidence for or against the emergence of consciousness in complex systems.