Bullets HITTING Bullets in Slow Motion - THE IMPOSSIBLE SHOT - Smarter Every Day 287

SmarterEveryDay SmarterEveryDay • Jun 09, 2023

Audio Brief

Show transcript
This episode covers an ambitious engineering project to recreate a rare historical artifact: two Civil War-era bullets that collided and fused together mid-air. There are three key takeaways from this discussion on scientific recreation and meticulous experimentation. First, high-stakes projects demand "intellectual humility," requiring expert review and meticulous planning for all conceivable failure modes to ensure safety. Second, when troubleshooting complex systems, meticulously isolate and test one variable at a time, as seemingly minor factors can cause significant and unpredictable failures. Third, visualizing scientific principles, such as the conservation of momentum through high-speed footage, can provide a powerful and intuitive understanding of complex physics. The project's primary goal was to replicate a Smithsonian artifact. Safety was paramount, guided by "intellectual humility," involving a team of engineering and explosives experts to rigorously "over-engineer" the setup. This principle emphasized acknowledging personal knowledge gaps and seeking specialized review for dangerous experiments. The team undertook rigorous troubleshooting to diagnose and solve aiming inconsistencies. This involved a deep dive into variables such as ammunition loading, gunpowder distribution, bullet seating, and equipment vibration, often utilizing 3D-printed models to visualize and pinpoint issues affecting bullet velocity. Using custom-built, electrically fired guns, which eliminated mechanical "lock time" for microsecond-level timing, and high-speed cameras, the team successfully captured multiple bullet collisions. The climax involved a near-perfect head-on collision where the conservation of momentum caused the fused mass to momentarily stop completely in mid-air before falling. This ambitious project showcases the scientific rigor and meticulous engineering essential for recreating historical phenomena and providing powerful visual insights into complex physical laws.

Episode Overview

  • The host embarks on a mission to recreate a rare historical artifact—two Civil War-era bullets that collided and fused together mid-air.
  • A significant portion of the project is dedicated to safety, emphasizing the principle of "intellectual humility" and involving a team of engineering and explosives experts to "over-engineer" the setup.
  • The experiment involves a rigorous troubleshooting process to diagnose and solve aiming inconsistencies, leading to a deep dive into variables like ammunition loading and equipment vibration.
  • Using custom-built, electrically fired guns and high-speed cameras, the team successfully captures multiple bullet collisions, including one with a near-perfect momentum transfer that causes the fused mass to stop in mid-air.

Key Concepts

  • The primary goal was to recreate a historical artifact from the Smithsonian: two Civil War bullets that collided and fused mid-air.
  • A core safety principle, "intellectual humility," guided the project, emphasizing the need for expert review and acknowledging personal knowledge gaps.
  • A custom-engineered system was built to overcome challenges, including an electrical firing system to eliminate the mechanical "lock time" of traditional firearms and ensure microsecond-level timing.
  • The experimental process involved rigorous troubleshooting of aiming inconsistencies by analyzing variables such as gunpowder distribution, bullet seating, and equipment vibration.
  • 3D-printed models were used to visualize and diagnose how inconsistencies in ammunition cartridges could affect bullet velocity.
  • The climax of the experiment involved capturing a near-perfect head-on collision in slow-motion, where the conservation of momentum caused the fused bullets to momentarily stop in mid-air before falling.
  • Different bullet types (lead, full metal jacket, hollow-point) were tested, which resulted in unique fragmentation and collision patterns upon impact.

Quotes

  • At 2:04 - "The way we did that is intellectual humility." - Destin explains that the key to conducting dangerous experiments safely is to humbly accept what you don't know and consult with experts.
  • At 5:13 - "Lock time is how long it takes the mechanical hammer to fall and strike the firing pin..." - Destin explains a key technical variable his team eliminated by building a custom electrical firing system for better timing.
  • At 15:34 - "At this point we got frustrated. We started missing things several times and we didn't know why." - The narrator describes the team's difficulty in diagnosing why their previously accurate setup began failing, highlighting the challenges of the experiment.
  • At 21:54 - "It stopped!" - The narrator expresses his astonishment while reviewing high-speed footage of two bullets colliding, where the resulting fused mass appears to stop completely in mid-air.
  • At 24:48 - "That looks like it, to me... Yes!" - After finding the remnants of the perfectly collided bullets on the ground, the team confirms they have recovered the unique artifact they set out to create.

Takeaways

  • For high-stakes projects, adopt a principle of "intellectual humility" by actively seeking expert review and planning for every conceivable failure mode to ensure safety.
  • When troubleshooting complex systems, meticulously isolate and test one variable at a time, as seemingly minor factors like a single loose nut can cause significant and unpredictable failures.
  • Visualizing scientific principles, such as the conservation of momentum, through high-speed footage can provide a powerful and intuitive understanding of complex physics.