Archeologists have discovered a mystery at the bottom of Lake Huron

Scientific American Scientific American May 31, 2021

Audio Brief

Show transcript
This episode covers the discovery of 9,000-year-old obsidian artifacts at the bottom of Lake Huron. There are three key takeaways from this finding. First, seemingly small archaeological discoveries can lead to monumental shifts in understanding ancient history. Second, unexpected environments like submerged lakebeds provide unique preservation sites for ancient landscapes and artifacts. Third, our perception of ancient peoples as simple is often incorrect, as evidence reveals their sophisticated technology and vast interconnected networks. Researchers found obsidian flakes originating from central Oregon, over 4,000 kilometers away. This challenges previous understandings of early hunter-gatherers' technological sophistication and social complexity. The findings on the now-submerged Alpena-Amberley Ridge indicate continent-wide trade or interaction networks. This discovery underscores the advanced capabilities and extensive connections of ancient North American societies.

Episode Overview

  • Researchers discovered 9,000-year-old artifacts at the bottom of Lake Huron on a now-submerged land bridge.
  • A tiny obsidian flake found at the site was chemically traced over 4,000 kilometers back to its geological source in central Oregon.
  • The discovery challenges previous understandings of ancient hunter-gatherers, revealing they had continent-wide social networks and unique, miniaturized tool technologies.

Key Concepts

  • Underwater Archaeology: The episode highlights the exploration of the Alpena-Amberley Ridge, a landform that was a dry land bridge 9,000 years ago but is now 100 feet below the surface of Lake Huron. This submerged landscape has preserved ancient hunting structures and artifacts.
  • Obsidian Sourcing: The researchers found flakes of obsidian, a volcanic glass not native to the Great Lakes. Through chemical analysis, they were able to pinpoint its origin to the Wagontire source in central Oregon, proving long-distance transport.
  • Ancient Trade Networks: The presence of Oregon obsidian in Michigan indicates that early hunter-gatherer societies were not isolated. They participated in vast, continent-scale networks of trade, interaction, and social connection.
  • Miniaturized Tool Assemblage: The stone tools found at the site were surprisingly small. Instead of the large spear points typical of the era, these people used a "miniaturized" technology, creating tiny microblades that were set into bone or antler handles to form composite tools.

Quotes

  • At 0:35 - "Somehow, at around 9,000 years ago, obsidian traveled 4,000 kilometers from the Pacific Northwest to the middle of what is now the Lake Huron basin." - John M. O'Shea explains the central mystery of how an artifact from so far away ended up at the underwater site.
  • At 2:08 - "It was absolutely obsidian. It was black, it was translucent, it was glassy. I determined after looking at it for just a few seconds that it couldn't be anything else." - Doctoral student Brendan Nash describes the moment he identified the crucial artifact while sorting through tiny sediment samples in the lab.
  • At 3:44 - "We should never, ever underestimate what these early people were capable of doing, and the complexity of their social life and of their technology." - John M. O'Shea summarizes the profound impact of the discovery on our understanding of ancient human societies.

Takeaways

  • Re-evaluate the capabilities of ancient peoples: This discovery proves that early hunter-gatherer societies were far more sophisticated and interconnected than often assumed, maintaining complex social and trade relationships across vast distances.
  • Details matter in scientific discovery: The game-changing obsidian flakes were found by accident in tiny vials of sediment collected for environmental analysis, underscoring that groundbreaking evidence can emerge from the most meticulous, small-scale examination.
  • Submerged landscapes are invaluable historical archives: The unique preservation conditions underwater can protect archaeological sites that would have been destroyed on land, offering an unaltered glimpse into the distant past and the potential to rewrite human history.